Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

No Upgrades, even for a Solitaire?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • No Upgrades, even for a Solitaire?

    I am a Solitaire member and have been flying SQ for over 20 years. In all that time I have never received a single complimentary upgrade - not even one.

    This is quite different from my experience on other airlines where I have similar status (I am 1K on United and Executive Platinum on American) and I am wondering why. I have heard tha some of my friends who are also Solitaire and even some who are just regular PPS do often get upgrades. Am I doing something wrong or does someone in SQ really dislike me?

    Any insights?

  • #2
    Welcome to SQTalk.

    I think if you look at the airlines in your post it tells you all you need to know. SQ don't do upgrades, and are one of the most profitable airlines in the world. US carriers hand upgrades out like confetti, and haven't regularly made profits since the ice age.

    I personally quite like SQ's policy of protecting the integrity of the cabin by not upgrading unless absolutely necessary, although I find their upgrade policy for F on the A380 quite pathetic and their ridiculous amount of miles they want for J on the A380 and 77W means I have shifted a lot of business elsewhere.

    For the record I have had two upgrades in all the years of flying SQ. First one was Y to F on BOM-MAN when I had no status on SQ at all and the second was J to F on a 744 while flying FRA-JFK, which was quite bizarre as it is the only time I ever saw that flight even approaching full.

    Comment


    • #3
      Welcome to SQT, Tokyo Solitaire.

      Originally posted by MAN Flyer View Post
      SQ don't do upgrades, and are one of the most profitable airlines in the world. [...] I personally quite like SQ's policy of protecting the integrity of the cabin by not upgrading unless absolutely necessary
      Not directed at you, MAN Flyer but the way some people say this (e.g. I've read it being hyped up to say that there's more chance of winning the lottery than getting an upgrade on SQ!) seems to indicate they think SQ is somehow unique in its upgrade policy. However, I think SQ's upgrade policy is actually no different than that of a lot of other airlines (no upgrade unless necessary) - except perhaps SQ's policy on F on the A380 (I haven't kept up with whether this has changed or not ?) - and SQ do upgrade more than just a few people out of necessity. Quite a number can be found on here!

      http://www.sqtalk.com/forum/showthread.php?t=91

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by jhm View Post
        Not directed at you, MAN Flyer but the way some people say this (e.g. I've read it being hyped up to say that there's more chance of winning the lottery than getting an upgrade on SQ!) seems to indicate they think SQ is somehow unique in its upgrade policy. However, I think SQ's upgrade policy is actually no different than that of a lot of other airlines (no upgrade unless necessary) - except perhaps SQ's policy on F on the A380 (I haven't kept up with whether this has changed or not ?) - and SQ do upgrade more than just a few people out of necessity. Quite a number can be found on here!

        http://www.sqtalk.com/forum/showthread.php?t=91
        Indeed, and I am not saying there aren't op-ups on SQ as I've had two myself. However, they are known to be notoriously stingy with them compared to other airlines, especially the US carriers, who were mentioned for comparison by the OP. The US airlines policy has always baffled me to be honest, handing it out for free.

        They do still have that anal A380 policy in place as well, which makes them look plain silly to be honest, especially as they have now quiety dropped that daft tag line.

        The best way to get an op-up on SQ is to be UMD it seems.

        Comment


        • #5
          Only complimentary upgrades I know of, at United, is the Unlimited Domestic Upgrades (and the complimentary upgrade instruments). Other than those, I don't think UA does complimentary upgrades either (for international flights). However, if Tokyo Solitaire was talking about op-ups, then it is a different matter altogether.
          Last edited by fone; 20 December 2010, 10:28 AM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by MAN Flyer View Post
            The best way to get an op-up on SQ is to be UMD it seems.
            That is, indeed.

            Comment


            • #7
              I think we're mistaking a strict upgrade policy for just plain old effective revenue management.

              I've lost count of the times where I've spent a whole day at the SKL chatting with the staff - finding out that "oh we're -25, -10 and 0" for tonight's flight , 5 hours before STD, and yet, when the time comes, doors close with 0,0 and 0 empty seats and no one having been upgraded nor bumped off.

              Amazing, and I've seen it happen so many times I'm beginning to wonder if they actually have a crystal ball.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by SQflyergirl View Post
                I think we're mistaking a strict upgrade policy for just plain old effective revenue management.
                I definitely think it's both, plus a continuing skeptical, even hostile, attitude towards frequent flyer perks.

                CX is perceived to be very generous about op-ups, even though it has the same policy of op-upping only when needed. I believe that a huge part of this is that its revenue management software is much less effective than SQ's. But then CX decided to make lemonade from its lemons, and use op-ups to generate FF goodwill. It hadn't degraded its front-cabin services to the same extent as the US-based airlines, so people really notice the value of the gesture.
                ‘Lean into the sharp points’

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by jjpb3 View Post
                  CX is perceived to be very generous about op-ups, even though it has the same policy of op-upping only when needed. I believe that a huge part of this is that its revenue management software is much less effective than SQ's.
                  Is this really true ? Looking at it simplistically, I think we have:

                  SQ selling less seats as a result of (presumably) a greater average price which means they don't op-up as much as CX; and the premium cabins can be said to be more exclusive (possibly encouraging some to pay (more) for them)

                  CX selling more seats at lower prices which means they have to op-up more than SQ (generating lots of FFP goodwill); but with less exclusive premium cabins as a result

                  I'm not sure that the former is definitely better than the latter ? To my simple way of seeing things, whether passengers are denied boarding (rather than whether opups are given) is a better measure of whether revenue management software is effective.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Originally posted by jhm View Post
                    I'm not sure that the former is definitely better than the latter ? To my simple way of seeing things, whether passengers are denied boarding (rather than whether opups are given) is a better measure of whether revenue management software is effective.
                    It seems to me that for SQ, the former is definitely better than the latter. From reports in the past that SQ preferred to deny boarding (and to offer compensation) rather than give op-ups, I would also seem that even a higher rate of passengers being denied boarding was preferable, if that served their definition of cabin integrity.
                    ‘Lean into the sharp points’

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by jjpb3 View Post
                      It seems to me that for SQ, the former is definitely better than the latter. From reports in the past that SQ preferred to deny boarding (and to offer compensation) rather than give op-ups, I would also seem that even a higher rate of passengers being denied boarding was preferable, if that served their definition of cabin integrity.
                      Never been denied boarding, and in fact was a recipient of several op-ups on SQ. This is especially so when I was doing SIN - MNL quite frequently. Y is almost always full while J is around 80%.

                      The crew told me they simply oversold Y and pushed people with status up. And I was only a lowly Elite Gold.
                      Life's A Bitch,
                      Love It

                      If GOD created me for only 1 reason. That reason would be to the love of my wife. If there was any other reasons involved, that would be for the love of Singapore Airlines

                      Flown with me? - http://my.flightmemory.com/inix

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Originally posted by inix View Post
                        Never been denied boarding, and in fact was a recipient of several op-ups on SQ. This is especially so when I was doing SIN - MNL quite frequently. Y is almost always full while J is around 80%.

                        The crew told me they simply oversold Y and pushed people with status up. And I was only a lowly Elite Gold.
                        I offer my dismal op-up rate on that very same route to help restore the balance. Happy to hear you were the beneficiary of the overbooking.

                        I have definitely heard of instances from a few years back (certainly a bit before the GFC) of people being offered compensation and the front cabin leaving with some empty seats. I can imagine that when the number of people who would need to be denied boarding goes past some threshold, op-ups would become the more financially attractive option to use.

                        In any case, I think the main point is that complimentary upgrades / op-ups on SQ are rare enough that it's best not to strategize about them (s/he isn't doing anything wrong), and it's best not to take their perennial scarcity personally (no one at SQ really dislikes her/him).
                        Last edited by jjpb3; 20 December 2010, 10:46 PM.
                        ‘Lean into the sharp points’

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Speaking of SIN-MNL that's one route where I received one of only two ever SQ op ups.

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            The difference in passenger variable cost between all three cabins will be a lot lower than the compensation cost of denied boarding, especially in stricter countries like EU. The revenue management strategy would incorporate the ability to upgrade a passenger. It's in no interest to the airline to deny boarding as it then displaces revenue seats on subsequent flights.The quicker you get rid of passengers the better.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by jhm View Post
                              Is this really true ? Looking at it simplistically, I think we have:

                              SQ selling less seats as a result of (presumably) a greater average price which means they don't op-up as much as CX; and the premium cabins can be said to be more exclusive (possibly encouraging some to pay (more) for them)

                              CX selling more seats at lower prices which means they have to op-up more than SQ (generating lots of FFP goodwill); but with less exclusive premium cabins as a result

                              I'm not sure that the former is definitely better than the latter ? To my simple way of seeing things, whether passengers are denied boarding (rather than whether opups are given) is a better measure of whether revenue management software is effective.
                              I think CX is cheaper only from SIN, once you get to HKG, they are the same price as SQ from SIN, and likely SQ from HKG is more cheaper than SQ from SIN. But I don't know, I'm just relying on common sense

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X